Shaft Macchio pulled up UNANNOUNCED to Olde City Cheesesteaks & Brew on Manhattan’s Upper East Side to find out if this NYC cheesesteak spot is really worth the hype. 👀🥩🔥
In Pot On The Spot Episode 10, Shaft takes on the Non-GMO Special Edition Reserve Cheesesteak — a special cheesesteak only served from 4–8 PM, 7 days a week at the Upper East Side location. And trust us…this one made an impression.
But the cheesesteak wasn’t the only thing getting put to the test. Shaft also tries the Old Bay Fries and washes it all down with a classic Old Fashioned Cocktail.
No invite. No special treatment. Shaft walked in like any other customer, paid for the meal himself, and gave Olde City the full Pot On The Spot treatment.
Was this one of the best cheesesteaks Shaft has found in NYC? And how many POTS did Olde City earn? 🍯🔥 You’ll have to watch until the verdict to find out.
📍 OLDE CITY CHEESESTEAKS & BREW – UPPER EAST SIDE
1664 3rd Ave
New York, NY 10128
Manhattan – Upper East Side
🌐 Olde City Website:
https://www.loveoldecity.com/
🔥 Watch More POT ON THE SPOT Episodes:
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLVB-rsYCHOK-3s-W865jeXMsS44xVQ9Oa
🍽️ Subscribe to Jumpin In The Pot:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC-wPs09tBJkUhkw2Y2wPsGQ
If you’re looking for NYC cheesesteaks, Upper East Side restaurants, Manhattan food reviews, affordable NYC eats, Philly-style cheesesteaks in New York, or hidden food spots in NYC, this episode belongs on your watchlist.
👇 Would YOU try the Reserve Cheesesteak? Drop your favorite NYC cheesesteak spot in the comments!
#PotOnTheSpot #OldeCityCheesesteaks #NYCFood #NYCFoodReview #Cheesesteak #UpperEastSide #ManhattanFood #NYCEats #ShaftMacchio #JumpinInThePot
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/jumpininthepot
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@jumpininthepot
X: https://x.com/jumpininthepot
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61551997795127
source
